On Second Thought

Share this post

What Danielle Smith Said...

anntomokorosen.substack.com

What Danielle Smith Said...

aka the scandal of our time (this week)

Ann Tomoko Rosen
Oct 13, 2022
12
6
Share this post

What Danielle Smith Said...

anntomokorosen.substack.com

Alberta’s new Premier Danielle Smith is in hot water. Here’s what she said:

The community that faced the most restrictions on their freedoms in the last year were those who made a choice not to be vaccinated. I don’t think I’ve ever experienced a situation in my lifetime where a person was fired from their job or not allowed to watch their kids play hockey or not allowed to visit a loved one in long-term care or hospice, or not allowed to go on a plane to either go across the country to see family or even travel across the border. So they have been the most discriminated against group that I’ve ever witnessed in my lifetime. That’s a pretty extreme level of discrimination that we have seen.

I don’t take away any of the discrimination I’ve seen in any of those groups that you mention, but this has been an extraordinary time in the last year in particular and I want people to know that I find that unacceptable. We are not going to create a segregated society on the basis of a medical choice.

Twitter avatar for @TPostMillennial
The Post Millennial @TPostMillennial
Alberta’s new Premier Danielle Smith on the unvaccinated: “They have been the most discriminated against group that I’ve ever witnessed in my lifetime.”
10:40 PM ∙ Oct 11, 2022
2,599Likes694Retweets

That, apparently, was enough to fuel outrage across mainstream and social media.

Here is one of the headlines (which seems to have since been deleted… at least I can’t find it)…

Twitter avatar for @ferryman4747
🇨🇦 The Ferryman's Toll 🇳🇱 @ferryman4747
"She basically claimed that the unvaccinated are people with rights... We haven't seen hate like this in Canada for decades" said antihate experts. #AbLeg #DanielleSmith #Alberta
Image
7:12 PM ∙ Oct 12, 2022
1,523Likes446Retweets

Conrad Nobert can’t remember anything more offensive from a Canadian official in his lifetime.

Twitter avatar for @conradnobert
Conrad Nobert @conradnobert
I can't remember a Canadian official ever saying anything more offensive in my entire lifetime than what Danielle Smith just said.
9:21 PM ∙ Oct 11, 2022
9,121Likes935Retweets

Really?

Twitter avatar for @Prairie29594275
Prairie Rose @Prairie29594275
@CTVNews "Do we tolerate these people?" Justin Trudeau #Discrimination
Image
5:47 PM ∙ Oct 12, 2022
61Likes17Retweets

Spencer Fernando has a different perspective:

After new Alberta Premier Danielle Smith said unvaccinated people faced the most discrimination of any group she has seen in her lifetime, the opinion gatekeepers came out of the woodwork to denounce her remarks.

She was predictably attacked as a ‘racist’ and all the other insults the left loves to throw at people in an attempt to get them to back down.

The fact is, Danielle Smith is correct. It is abundantly clear that unvaccinated Canadians faced the most direct and relentless state-sponsored discrimination of any group in recent Canadian history.

Unvaccinated Canadians were banned from travel, often banned from workplaces, banned from seeing their families, and more. The politicians who imposed those policies knew they were wrong, as evidenced by Justin Trudeau previously speaking out against vaccine mandates before imposing them when he feared losing an election.

Here’s a sampling of some of the ways other’s interpreted her remarks…

Twitter avatar for @birgitomo
Birgit Uwaila Umaigba 🇳🇬 @birgitomo
It is my hope that all of Canada is waking up to condemn Danielle Smith's very privileged definition of discrimination. This white privileged Premier of Alberta has no clue what it means to be discriminated against.
1:05 PM ∙ Oct 12, 2022
4,684Likes713Retweets
Twitter avatar for @JanisIrwin
Janis Irwin @JanisIrwin
Danielle Smith has shown us who she is. Call her hate out, absolutely. But then take that energy and use it for good. I’m spending my day in meetings with community. Later, I’m knocking on doors. There’s much to fight against. Let’s fight *for* the Alberta we know is possible.
4:58 PM ∙ Oct 12, 2022
2,473Likes322Retweets
Twitter avatar for @NaheedD
Naheed Dosani @NaheedD
So...Danielle Smith thinks unvaccinated people are the most discriminated against group she's ever seen. Someone please tell her about: Missing & Murdered Indigenous Women. Residential Schools. Systemic racism. Genocide. This is what discrimination actually looks like.
11:50 AM ∙ Oct 12, 2022
4,519Likes776Retweets
Twitter avatar for @TheRealKeean
Keean Bexte @TheRealKeean
The media will talk about Danielle Smith for the next week. They don't want you knowing about the TrudeauTrial.com that is taking place in Ottawa tomorrow.
11:11 PM ∙ Oct 12, 2022
4,238Likes2,052Retweets
Twitter avatar for @CartesnDuelist
Cartesian Duelist @CartesnDuelist
Wow I can't believe Danielle Smith dared say the unvaccinated were discriminated against. It's like she thinks they were denied job opportunities, put into financial destitution, barred from public places, and a had a war measures act put against them.
4:05 PM ∙ Oct 12, 2022
2,366Likes496Retweets
Twitter avatar for @TheoFleury14
Theo Fleury @TheoFleury14
The fact that no MSM or politicians are talking about Pfizer today and talking only about Danielle Smith is an absolute disgrace of how much the whole lot of them media/politicians are in on this scamdemic. Easy to put the puzzle together. They are using you.
11:26 PM ∙ Oct 12, 2022
4,713Likes1,417Retweets
Twitter avatar for @aaronhoyland
Aaron Hoyland @aaronhoyland
Say what you will about Danielle Smith, but I actually learn a lot from her. For example, I had no idea that you could sleep through every science AND history lesson since third grade and still become premier.
4:14 PM ∙ Oct 12, 2022
6,547Likes678Retweets
Twitter avatar for @NormalGuy223
Joe Blo @NormalGuy223
Danielle Smith thinks all people should be treated equally regardless of their medical status....and according to the left, this makes her a white supremacist. 🤡🤡🤡🤡🤡🤡🤡🤡🤡🤡🤡🤡🤡
11:26 PM ∙ Oct 12, 2022
874Likes248Retweets
Twitter avatar for @jmclennan8
James M. @jmclennan8
Interesting local poll. Looks like some people quietly agree Danielle Smith in the Okanagan.
Image
7:48 PM ∙ Oct 13, 2022
6Likes2Retweets

I imagine she saw this coming… Here she is talking about hate speech in 2019.

I’ve been involved in conservative politics for a long, long time, and I remember all the way back when I was a kid, going to rallies, when Stockwell Day for example was leader at the federal level…and the outside protester’s chants were “racist, sexist, anti-gay, Stockwell Day, go away.”

It continues to be the mantra, I think, of people who don’t want to talk about their record. I think what we’re seeing is they take statements out of context that sound a little bit on the edge and then turn it into a full-blown scandal.

I guess the little bit on the edge part was the use of superlatives? Maybe Smith should have qualified discrimination against the unvaccinated as “the most government-endorsed, culturally accepted discrimination” she has witnessed in her lifetime.

I kind of wish she had said it that way. I’d be curious to see the tweets.

Meanwhile, according to True North, “A Danielle Smith government would amend the Alberta Human Rights Act to prohibit employers from firing employees based on their vaccination status.”

I really hope this happens. When it does, I wonder how that will be framed as a hate crime in Canada. Trudeau will probably find a way.

In the meantime, I’m thinking this…

Twitter avatar for @CoryBMorgan
Cory Morgan @CoryBMorgan
Legacy media outlets are almost universally lined up against Danielle Smith. That is a great endorsement.
12:36 PM ∙ Oct 12, 2022
1,908Likes416Retweets

6
Share this post

What Danielle Smith Said...

anntomokorosen.substack.com
6 Comments
Dr. Vítor Oliveira
Writes Equilibrando a Vida e a Saúde
Oct 13, 2022Liked by Ann Tomoko Rosen

We need a simple formula to add to any speech to "immunize" it from such leftist irrationality.

Expand full comment
Reply
3 replies by Ann Tomoko Rosen and others
JohnL
Oct 13, 2022Liked by Ann Tomoko Rosen

I read about Danielle Smith on another site last night. Very courageous of her. Made me feel the tide may have turned, at least in Alberta, based on all the comments on that other site. Sad to see the accusations of hate on some of the twitter pieces, hoping that's not representative.

Thanks for posting this!

Expand full comment
Reply
1 reply by Ann Tomoko Rosen
4 more comments…
TopNewCommunity

No posts

Ready for more?

© 2023 Ann Tomoko Rosen
Privacy ∙ Terms ∙ Collection notice
Start WritingGet the app
Substack is the home for great writing